The Gibson offers one of the best whiskey selections in New York. We have more than 100 different varieties of whisk(e)y, including Bourbon, Scotch, and Irish.

Bourbon

9.00 Jim Beam


11.00 Buffalo Trace


9.00 Wild Turkey


11.00 Eagle Rare


9.00 Jim Beam Black


10.00 Bulleit


10.00 Maker’s Mark


12.00 Four Roses Single Barrel


10.00 Michters Bourbon


9.00 Old Bardstown


11.00 Ridgemont Reserve 1792


12.00 Rowan’s Creek


9.00 Sam Houston


12.00 Willett Family Reserve


10.00 Berkshire


13.00 Blanton’s


10.00 Johnny Drum Private Stock


10.00 Knob Creek


11.00 Woodford Reserve


12.00 Bakers


11.00 Basil Hayden


11.00 McKenzie Bourbon Chardonnay Finish


14.00 Noah’s Mill


14.00 Old Pogue


14.00 Angels Envy Port Finish


15.00 Prichard’s Double Barreled


16.00 Booker’s


30.00 Michter’s 10 Year


35.00 Pappy Van Winkle 12 Year


55.00 Pappy Van Winkle 15 Year


40.00 Angel’s Envy Cask Strength


9.00 Bird Dog


11.00 Black Dirt Crown Maple Bourbon


12.00 Blade and Bow


15.00 Bootlegger 21 New York


11.00 Breaking & Entering


13.00 Bulleit 10yr


16.00 Col E.H. Taylor Small Batch


9.00 Cyrus Noble


10.00 Elijah Craig Small Batch


12.00 Elmer T. Lee Single Barrel


18.00 Garrison Brothers Texas Straight Bourbon


16.00 Grass Widow


16.00 High West Campfire


18.00 Hillrock Single Malt Whiskey


16.00 Hillrock Solera


15.00 Hudson Baby Bourbon


11.00 I.W. Harper


9.00 James E. Pepper 1776


40.00 Jefferson Presidential 25yr


15.00 Jefferson’s Cabernet Finish


12.00 Jefferson’s Collaboration


15.00 Jefferson’s Ocean


12.00 Jefferson’s Reserve Very Old


10.00 Jefferson’s Very Small Batch


10.00 Larceny


9.00 Lexington


12.00 Michter’s Toasted Oak


9.00 Old Forrester


25.00 Old Rip Van Winkle 10yr


14.00 Oola


12.00 Rusell’s Bourbon 10yr


17.00 Sam Houston 10yr


14.00 Smooth Ambler Contradiction


12.00 Smooth Ambler Old Scout


15.00 Smooth Ambler Old Scout 10yr


14.00 Van Brunt Stillhouse Bourbon


14.00 Van Brunt Stillhouse Single Malt


11.00 Very Old Barton


14.00 Weller 12yr


14.00 Weller Antique 107


14.00 Weller Special Reserve


14.00 Widow Jane 10yr


12.00 Woodford Reserve Double Oak


11.00 Wyoming Whiskey



Rye

8.00 Old Overholt


9.00 Jim Beam


9.00 Rittenhouse


9.00 Wild Turkey


10.00 Bulleit Rye


11.00 Sazerac


9.00 Redemption


11.00 McKenzie Rye


11.00 Michters Straight Rye


12.00 Willett


10.00 High West Double Rye


40.00 Jefferson Reserve 25 Year Rye


11.00 Templeton


18.00 Whistle Pig 10yr


15.00 1512 Spirits Rye


16.00 Angel’s Envy Rye


16.00 Col.E.H. Taylor Rye


12.00 Corsair Rymageddon


14.00 Few Rye


10.00 Filibuster


10.00 George Dickel Rye


12.00 Gunpowder Rye


16.00 High West Bourye


14.00 High West Rendezvous Rye


16.00 High West Yipee-Ki-Yay


16.00 Hillrock Double Cask Rye


15.00 Hudson Manhattan Rye


9.00 James E. Pepper 1776


11.00 Knob Creek Rye


20.00 Lock Stock & Barrel Straight Rye


35.00 Michter’s 10yr Rye


18.00 Michter’s Barrel Strength Rye


15.00 Michter’s Toasted Barrel Rye


20.00 Midwinter Nights Dram


10.00 No. 4 Westchester Rye


12.00 Prichard’s Rye


11.00 Ragtime Rye


11.00 Rebellious Rye


12.00 Smooth Ambler Rye


9.00 Tap 357 Canadian Maple Rye


12.00 Town Branch Rye


15.00 Two James Catcher’s Rye


14.00 Van Brunt Stillhouse Rye


40.00 Whistle Pig 15yr


25.00 Whistle Pig Old World 12yr


12.00 Widow Jane Rye



Irish

9.00 Powers


10.00 Jameson


9.00 John L. Sullivan


10.00 Bushmills


9.00 Paddy’s


9.00 Tullamore Dew


10.00 Slieve Foy


11.00 Jameson Black Barrel


10.00 Michael Collins 10 Yr


12.00 Powers 12 Year Special Reserve


14.00 Red Breast 12 Year


17.00 Red Breast 15 Year


11.00 Black Bush


12.00 Bushmills 10yr


10.00 Jameson Caskmates


10.00 Teeling Irish Whiskey


10.00 West Cork Single Malt 10yr



Tennessee

9.00 George Dickel No. 12


9.00 Jack Daniel’s


10.00 Gentleman Jack


10.00 George Dickel No. 8


9.00 Jailer’s



Other Whiskey

9.00 Wild Turkey Honey


9.00 High West Silver OMG Pure Rye


10.00 Michter’s American Whiskey


9.00 Old Stampede Canadian Whiskey


9.00 Whipper Snapper Whiskey


9.00 White Pike Whiskey


18.00 Hirsch 20 Year American Whiskey


12.00 Beacon American Whiskey


12.00 Iron Smoke Apple wood Smoked


11.00 JP Wiser’s Canadian Rye


10.00 Michter’s Sour Mash


10.00 Smooth Ambler Old Scout American


12.00 Two James Johnny Smoking Gun


12.00 Van Brunt Stillhouse American Whiskey



Scotch (Single Malt)

16.00 Singleton 18 Year


14.00 Auchentoshen


9.00 Glenkinchie


11.00 Balvenie Doublewood 12 Year


16.00 GlenLivet 15 Year


12.00 Glenmorangie


12.00 Laphroig 10 Year


12.00 Macallan 12 Year


11.00 Ardbeg 10 Year


12.00 Bunnahabhain 12 Year


11.00 Glenfiddich 12 Year


16.00 Oban


14.00 Balvenie 14 Year Caribbean Rum Cask


16.00 Balvenie 15 Year Single Barrel


16.00 Lagavulin 16 Year


12.00 Aberlour


11.00 Bowmore 12


12.00 Bruichladdich Islay Barley


12.00 Bruichladdich Scottish Barley


15.00 Bunnahabhain Toiteach


14.00 Dalmore 12 Year


16.00 Dalmore 15 Year


25.00 Dalmore 18 Year


25.00 Dalmore Cigar Malt


22.00 Glenmorangie 18 Year Extremely Rare


12.00 Glenmorangie La Santa


50.00 Hakushu 18 Year


10.00 Highland Park 12 Year


12.00 Jura Brooklyn


16.00 Laphroaig 15 Year


11.00 Talisker 10 Year


15.00 Talisker Storm


12.00 GlenLivet



Scotch (Blended)

10.00 Dewars


9.00 Johnnie Walker Red


9.00 Pig’s Nose


12.00 Johnnie Walker Black


11.00 Compass Box The Great King


12.00 Compass Box The Peat Monster


10.00 Cutty Sark Prohibition Edition


16.00 Eades Small Batch Double Malt


9.00 The Black Grouse


10.00 Virginia Highlands